Democracy & ResistanceThinking Patterns & Narratives

Thought #481: Where my “kindly tongue” reaches its limit

Published on

I have even more thoughts in my head right now that simply move me, that I want to sort out and that I want to share. Even if, at least at first, maybe nobody reads them, they still have to be shared – they simply have to get out into the world. And I’m back with Napoleon Hill: the Cosmic Habit Force.

Not a “conflict” but an invasion: the mantra “as long as the rouble keeps rolling”

In this context we are in right now, we have a war that broke out in February/March 2022 – and the whole thing was preceded by borders in Europe being moved again in 2014 by an aggressor, and him testing how the so-called democratic, firm, shining West would react. And the West reacted exactly the way the dictator and war criminal expected: namely, not at all.

The West simply watched, because in the West a sham democracy rules, and the real mantra in the so-called West, in the EU, is: “Anything goes, as long as the rouble keeps rolling – and as long as it doesn’t affect us.” That’s our motto. After the Second World War, too, we very quickly forgot what “Never again fascism” and “Never again war” actually mean.

And sometimes I’ve been asked by people I talked with about this whole topic of Ukraine and war and energy and prices and so on: “Well, so what’s your solution? How could this so-called conflict be solved?”

And right there, I think, is the first error in thinking: It is not a conflict, it is a brutal attack. An aggressor attacks his small neighbour, who is weaker than he is. It’s like in the schoolyard when the bully simply smashes a weaker kid in the face because he knows he’s stronger. Or when a man rapes a woman because the man knows he is physically stronger. Or when a stronger predator attacks and eats another animal – though this comparison limps again: because the predator eats because that is how the food chain is set up and it draws its food from it, while with humans it is a conscious decision, and humans are not forced to hurt, destroy, exploit other humans.

5,000 helmets and bureaucracy: how could Putin’s invasion have been stopped?

So the question is: how could Putin and his invasion have been stopped, at the very latest after the brutal attack?

And here I unfortunately have to confess that until then I had still hoped that we as a nation would make the right decisions – and then the dilemma really began, and more or less the shame too. I remember we had an SPD defence minister back then in 2022, and she went and sent 5,000 steel helmets to Ukraine. That was the answer of Germany and of NATO.

And NATO is the strongest military alliance in the world. And NATO, all in all, has done nothing so far except watch and bureaucratically push files back and forth and discuss. So Germany first discussed for a long time. The Americans quickly delivered Javelins and other more or less hand-held weapons – larger hand-held weapons, you could say – that was still under Biden, for self-defence. Because that is a huge issue in this war: it is about self-defence. It is not about destruction, it is about the self-defence of a sovereign nation, just as we actually agreed after 1945.

And to make this self-defence possible – to enable Ukraine to defend itself – Germany in the end only delivered something to Ukraine on paper, but did not really, seriously support Ukraine militarily. So it took forever until we finally delivered a handful of Leopards, which came far too late and were no longer up to date. And we discussed forever whether we would now deploy the Taurus or not – and in the end Merz too, contrary to his promise, did not allow Ukraine to use the Taurus.

So, to answer the question of how Putin could have been stopped, how he could be stopped now: I see two big fields there:

1. Sanctions without loopholes (including an IT shutdown)

The first big field is sanctions. It is a disgrace and ridiculous that we pass what feels like the 500th so-called sanctions package and it has no effect. Had we really wanted to sanction Putin, we could have. But there are so many loopholes in these sanctions that they don’t really work:

  • keyword shadow fleet,
  • but the frozen capital of the oligarchs isn’t used either,
  • technology from the West can still be used,
  • and we haven’t used our influence on China either, although we could – we don’t want to, because otherwise the rouble stops rolling for the shareholders.

So sanctions: we failed there. In my view, for example, Microsoft and all American software providers could have switched Russia off completely – or rather they could have cut off the Russian leadership, the NKVD in its modern form, that is the FSB. Because the Russians have no IT of their own, they have no software system of their own, they have no internet of their own. Without the Americans and American technologies they can do nothing – null, niente, nothing. So sanctions: we completely failed on that level.

2. Military support for self-defence – and our missed historic chance with the Taurus

And the second level is military support for self-defence, because of course we should have delivered the Taurus, among other things, so that Ukraine itself could destroy military infrastructure in Russia in a very targeted way. That would have been the imperative of the hour. That means we would not have sent ground troops – although, in my view, that should actually have been discussed too, but fine, let’s leave that aside, it would probably have been political suicide, it couldn’t have been pushed through. But we absolutely should have got the release of the Taurus through!

Because of course under international law Ukraine has the right to defend itself, and that includes destroying military infrastructure on the territory of the war criminal, the enemy in this war. This is about military infrastructure, not civilian infrastructure and not civilians. With precise information, with the support of the American intelligence services, with the support of the private individual Elon Musk – who has all this information and decides over life and death with it like a lord – with that the West could have enabled Ukraine to decimate Putin’s rotten military infrastructure in a targeted way within the shortest time. That is what I would have expected from a functioning NATO.

I believe that here, as a nation, we really have missed a historic chance. There’s a song by Silly called Vaterland (“Fatherland”). It must have come out around 2010 – so about 15, 16 years ago. Interestingly, it begins with what I think is a Russian church choir, for whatever reason, I don’t know what the connection is. And there’s the line: “How do I love such a country – with heart or mind, somehow staring at the wall or looking beyond the rim of the plate”, something like that. It is a very critical song, and I don’t think many Germans like it – but I like it, because it is self-critical and at its core says that we Germans are above all a nation that has manufactured and used weapons.

For example, “Big Bertha” comes to mind – that sounds very cute, but it was one of the gigantic German weapons projects – and under Hitler there were of course the V1 and the V2, and there German engineers made sure that human lives were destroyed.

And now we would have had the historic chance with the Taurus to make sure that human lives are saved and that peace is established – and we are simply missing this chance! The Taurus is probably also one of the few fields where we Germans are still technology leaders. In all other fields we have fallen far behind, for example when it comes to digitalisation: Ukrainian women are shocked that in Germany we have paper bureaucracy.

The Hague, Bucha and where my “kindly tongue” reaches its limit

NATO’s last sensible mission, in my view, was in the 1990s, when in the end, finally, after a long time – there, too, people watched for a very long time as a genocide took place in Europe – the Clinton administration finally brought itself to end the Milošević massacre and his war crimes by having NATO take him out with targeted air strikes. And then Milošević, just as the civilised world had actually laid down, was put before an international court in The Hague, him and his henchmen.

And exactly the same should have been done with Putin, at the very latest after Bucha. But there, too, we watched. We all close our eyes and talk and blather and waffle, and people are still dying. And I don’t just find that sad – it simply makes me, I don’t know how to put it: there I lose the wire and the connection to the “kindly tongue”. I don’t know how I can stay kind there. Yes, that just had to come out.

Show fact-check & sources
Something to think about

Who would you like to talk to about this thought?

Three ways from here