Democracy & ResistanceThinking Patterns & Narratives

Thought #479: “The Soviet soldiers saved me”: How a Soviet soldier gave my mother food in Niederwiesa in May 1945 – and why we, as Saxons and people of the Ore Mountains, must not abandon Ukraine today

Published on

Last night I watched maischberger, and among other things the question came up: how will things go on with Ukraine, now that Putin, Trump and Xi are meeting? There were different opinions, and among others Ulrike Herrmann said there will only be peace once Putin has died. As long as Putin is alive, he will wage war. And she said that this is the hard reality, that everything else is just hot air and diversionary tactics, and that we in the West have more or less made ourselves comfortable behind the protective wall of NATO and are now waiting to see what Ukraine does.

And that was a shock for me. Because I believe the probability is very high that she is right with this forecast – and that would be dramatic and terrible. And that's why I think a lot about Ukraine, about its survival, its future, and my time at the Schule am Palmengarten in Leipzig, where I worked very intensively with Ukrainian kids and tried to meet them where they were, to protect them, to accompany them and to prepare the next steps for them.

Niederwiesa in May 1945: “The Soviet soldiers saved me”

And I took that as a reason to simply look into which units, which parts of the Red Army liberated Chemnitz and the south in 1945 – that is, my home region and the home region of my parents.

Why? Because my mother told me that she and her mother, my grandma, were saved by Soviet soldiers. She always spoke of Soviet soldiers. She never said “Russians”, always “Soviet soldiers”: “The Soviet soldiers saved me.”

Why? Because in that time, 1945, there was hunger among the population, among the Germans. And as a child my mum saw people collapse in front of her on the street from hunger and drop dead. And the rumour was very widespread that now the Russians were coming and would rape all the women. My grandpa was still a prisoner of war, and so my mother was alone with her mother. And they were so afraid of the Russians – above all my grandma – that they hid in the cellar. But they were hungry. My mother was starving. And she couldn't bear it.

I still knew my grandma: she was very reserved and would never have dared to go out, and they had almost starved in the cellar. Then my mother went out of the cellar – or a Soviet soldier found her – and he gave her food and more or less saved her, her and my grandma. So these Soviet soldiers, against the rumours and against the fear, were not evil at all – quite the opposite: they were very friendly and very humane and saved my mother and my grandma from starving to death. And that meant that my sister and I were born, that I can write this now, and that I can help Ukrainian children.

A holiday in Saxony – and a question after almost 57 years

And now I asked the AI. Today is a public holiday in Saxony, and I'm sitting here and I'm crying.

Why? Because today, almost 57 years after I was born, I asked the AI: where did these Soviet soldiers actually come from? It never really interested me, because for me Soviet soldiers were always Soviet soldiers – they spoke Russian, and I learned Russian with them.

And the AI says they were 99% Ukrainian people. (Checked: 99% is too high. But there were very many – in some armies of the 1st Ukrainian Front, which also took Chemnitz in May 1945, more than half of the soldiers came from Ukraine in 1944. The sources are in the fact check below.)

And that's where the circle closes. Do I want to say that Ukrainian people are better than Russian people? No. But is it symbolic, and is it very emotional for me? Absolutely, yes.

The mid-80s in the Ore Mountains: Soviet soldiers again – and again I didn't ask

And the bridge goes on. In the mid-80s, somewhere between '84 and '88, I kept spending time with the Soviet soldiers: with my father at the garrison in Karl-Marx-Stadt – and in the forest near Reitzenhain, where I sat by the stove in their military vehicle with Soviet soldiers (Thought #95). That's who I learned my Russian with. There were probably Ukrainians among them too. Back then I simply didn't pay attention to it. It just wasn't a topic. They spoke Russian, and so to me they were Soviet soldiers (Thought #454).

And it was exactly this Russian that made it possible for me in 2022, at the Schule am Palmengarten, to meet the Ukrainian kids where they were, to protect them and to accompany them. 1945 in Niederwiesa, the mid-80s in Reitzenhain, 2022 in Leipzig – for me, that is a circle.

One biological species – and why our diversity has to survive

Does that mean Ukrainian people are better than Russian people or German people? Of course not.

German people committed the worst atrocities humankind has ever seen. The Nazis were Germans. What they did in the concentration and extermination camps, what they did in Ukraine, those massacres, what they did in Stalingrad and in so many other places – it is unimaginable, it goes beyond what I can imagine. And those were Germans. Does that mean Germans are inherently worse people than others? No.

Did Serbian people commit crimes in Srebrenica? Yes. Was Milošević a war criminal and a Serb? Yes. Does that make Serbs worse people than Croats or other ethnic groups? No.

The Khmer Rouge tortured and annihilated people. Does that make Cambodian people worse than Vietnamese people? No.

And so on. The list can go on forever. If we were to say now that certain ethnic groups are worse than others, that thought is wrong – it isn't true.

We always speak of people. And people are one biological species whose genes match. There is only one species on this planet that is intelligent, and that's us: Homo sapiens. And in the end we have to solve big challenges – namely: how do we use this planet so that it can go on being the basis of our lives? That means: if we now start trying to find out which ethnic group is better than another, we have all already lost.

But what matters is that languages survive, and that Ukrainian goes on existing. Ukrainian culture, the Ukrainian language, the Ukrainian mentality – what makes these people who they are. Because we people from the Ore Mountains want to stay people from the Ore Mountains, and we Saxons want to stay Saxons, and the Germans want to stay Germans. Diversity has to survive. We mustn't all be the same and speak the same, like Americans or like the Chinese, Mandarin – there has to be diversity.

“Never again” – a promise my generation still has to keep

My grandparents and my parents told my sister and me again and again: it has to be a consensus for us that war must never again start from German soil. And “never again” also means: there must never again be fascism. But that doesn't only apply to Germany, it applies at least to Europe – and to other regions where we have influence, too. And this is where I now see the danger that we as a generation simply didn't manage it. My generation hasn't made “never again” real.

As a Saxon and a man of the Ore Mountains: let's remember who liberated us

That's why, as a Saxon and as someone from the Ore Mountains, I find it all the more shameful that we in Saxony now allow political currents to shout louder and louder for Ukrainians to capitulate and to want to stop supporting Ukrainians.

To put it positively: that makes it all the more important that we remember who liberated us. It isn't that long ago – two generations – that we were liberated from our own fascists, because we couldn't manage it on our own. It was the Red Army, and it consisted to a large extent of people from the European part of the Soviet Union, and so above all from Ukraine. They got us out of a mess. They protected us, they liberated us.

And what are we doing now? We sit there and more or less watch. I don't think that's right.

My dear fellow people of the Ore Mountains

At this point I'd like to say something more – to everyone who, like me, comes from the Ore Mountains.

My dear fellow people, I too grew up with our dialect and with the stories and poems of Anton Günther. And Christmas was a very Ore-Mountain time for me too. I'm a man of the Ore Mountains through and through. I'm a winter sports person, I did winter sports in the Ore Mountains and for a long time I had my roots in the region. And of course I know about all the difficulties our region has right now.

And that's exactly why I believe it's important that we look at Ukraine's situation from a new perspective, because it wasn't “the Russians” who liberated us back then. Among the soldiers who liberated our region there were very many Ukrainians.

When people in this debate now say we should make peace with Russia – which isn't possible like that – and send the Ukrainians home: think it over again, calmly. Is that really the answer? Shouldn't we, as people of the Ore Mountains, show more humanity and more greatness – and now reach out a hand to the people whose fathers and grandfathers gave their lives for us back then, and support them in this difficult time?

That's what we're about, isn't it – it makes us more human. And in the end it's a gain for us, too. We need a next generation, we need children. Why can't they also be Ukrainian children and young people who bring a new perspective? Please think about it calmly – and don't let propaganda lull you.

Why, for my mother and me, the circle closes today

For me this is a personal and very emotional and very close connection that I have now, and that I will also share with my mother, because she's still alive. And she didn't know this. She never made a distinction. But now it may be interesting after all to work through it – for us, that is, for me. Because history simply happened in such a way that I very probably owe my life to Ukrainian people, and my mother's life too.

And I'd like to share this with all the Ukrainian people I know – and with my fellow people in the Ore Mountains and in Saxony.

Food for thought

If the people who got us out of a mess two generations ago are fighting today for their own language, their culture and their freedom: what can we do here in Saxony so that we don't just watch?

Show fact-check & sources
Something to think about

Who would you like to talk to about this thought?

Three ways from here