Democracy & ResistancePower & Self-Organization

Thought #485: What “never again” means when we look honestly

Published
· Updated

You can’t take it in, you can’t really grasp it

As a child, of course, I read and learned a great deal about how barbaric it was in the concentration camps and how many atrocities and which atrocities the Nazis committed. But it is so incomprehensible that it takes me years, and that even now I still haven’t really processed and internalised all of it; it was information, and then the brain blocks: you can’t take it in, you can’t really grasp it. That’s why I watch things like that, for example documentaries about Auschwitz, because I don’t believe there has ever been anything worse in human history.

There were the Khmer Rouge, there were the Belgians in the Congo, there were unbelievably many genocides, but on an industrial level, the way the Germans did it, with this precision and with this cold-bloodedness, with this inhumanity – that is, I believe, unique in history. And in my view, as a nation we have by far not really acknowledged it yet, haven’t engaged with it the way we would have to, and haven’t drawn enough conclusions for our present and for our future. There is still an enormous lack of coming to terms with history, and denazification did not really take place in any deep sense.

Because if we had come to terms with it, we would take a different stance

I’m watching a documentary on ZDF right now, it’s about Auschwitz, the title is “Auschwitz – Überleben in der Hölle” (Auschwitz – Surviving in Hell). And once again it shows the path the Germans took, from the supposedly democratic Weimar Republic to the Shoah, to the Holocaust. Of course there is a great deal of literature, a great deal of research has been done on the causes, it is all well documented and known. And yet, I believe, as a nation we haven’t really and seriously come to terms with it. Because if we had come to terms with it, we would also take a different stance on Gaza and on the war in Ukraine. Then we would be aware that we have an unbelievably great responsibility here and, above all, would have to act.

At the core, the Nazis first very cautiously, but systematically and with a goal, eliminated the left-wing opposition and simply locked up Social Democrats and Communists without trial in so-called collection camps, concentration camps. Dachau, the concentration camp near Munich, was a pilot project of the Nazis. There, violence was systematically established as a core element, as the central element, and it was in the hands of the SS from the very beginning.

And what did the bourgeois middle – millions of educated, decent Germans – do when they saw the Nazis first classify the Jews as a race with the Nuremberg Laws and dehumanise them? The overwhelming, shocking majority of civilised, educated, democratic Germans simply watched, or rather applauded.

Noble be man, helpful and good

Leipzig prides itself on having a past shaped above all by Goethe. We have Auerbachs Keller, and as a student he supposedly wrote his Faust there and rode on the barrel, on the wine barrel, and we lead tourists from all over the world through it, and they have to book a table at Auerbachs Keller in advance, and we let ourselves be celebrated for it. And Goethe praised Leipzig and said: “My Leipzig I commend, it is a little Paris” and so on. And then we learned poems by Goethe, The Sorcerer’s Apprentice, and Faust we read up and down and interpreted it and still love him and are proud of Goethe and of Schiller too, his friend. We do have the Schiller House in Leipzig. There is one quote above all that I took away from Goethe. It is very easy to remember and very short. It goes: “Noble be man, helpful and good.”

And I ask myself what my grandparents’ generation didn’t understand about this quote. How could they allow it – after Goethe had created all these works in our language, and we had read them, and they too had already engaged with them – that suddenly another person takes power who then says: nope, “noble be man, helpful and good”, that’s not the case at all. There is no such thing as the human being; there are races, human races, and there is a classification, a hierarchy. And in this hierarchy there is one race, that is the master race, those are the so-called Aryans, and only they have the right to live, and those are the so-called Volksdeutsche, and we are a people without space, and that’s why we are now going to subjugate the whole world and make the whole world subject to us. How could we get from Goethe’s “Noble be man, helpful and good” to “Führer, command, we follow you” and “Do you want total war?”, to all this terrible conditioning? What exactly went wrong there?

The language of Goethe and Schiller was misused as an instrument

And also the language the Nazis used and created: the “Final Solution of the Jewish Question”. “Solution” means something positive, and “final” means definitive – you have solved a problem once and for all. And “Jewish Question”. And this runs through the entire Nazi era, how they reinterpreted language and how they misused language. The language of Goethe and Schiller was misused as an instrument. And that’s why we have to be very careful how we handle our language. And in some public authorities I don’t see any coming to terms with this yet either. There are still very many terms there that are highly questionable and have a negative vibration. There too we see that we haven’t consistently come to terms with this disgrace of our history.

We can’t claim to be a highly civilised society

When it comes to judging what we achieve as Germans, we see ourselves as the nation of thinkers and poets and of science and of great names, philosophers like Nietzsche. And then we also had Einstein, who was Jewish, after all, and had to flee. Even the right wing, I believe, stands by Goethe – at least I hope so. But we can’t claim to be a highly civilised society when two, three generations ago the majority of Germans believed that there are inferior races and that there are racial characteristics, and that pseudo-scientists like Josef Mengele were allowed to carry out these cruel and barbaric experiments, or that the SS were allowed to make shrunken heads in the concentration camps, or that the citizens of Weimar got upset that their air was being polluted because the burned Jewish corpses had too little fat. These are all cruel things.

Or when industry delivered new ovens so that more Jews could be gassed, Zyklon B for example. The whole of industry took part, the industry we are now so proud of. VW, BMW, all these big names – they first really grew fat through the Nazis, or only came into being at all through this racial madness. And all of this stretches on to this day. We haven’t really processed it. So we’re simply lying to ourselves when we say we have closed the chapter on our past. You can’t take that seriously.

I lack the word

We Germans are generally known for being proud of our engineering achievements, and to some extent we certainly can be. To some extent, though, we also have to admit that in the war of annihilation, above all in the Second World War, this took on a scale that is simply unbelievably horrifying. It is so abysmally inhuman. I lack the word. What is the word for it? I keep struggling for a fitting term. Claude and Gemini, what is the word for the precision with which the Germans – after they found that, above all on the Eastern Front, they had shot around 2 million, I believe, Jews, that this takes a very long time, this shooting, that it isn’t fast enough to annihilate the people – and that then Mengele, I believe, came up with the “brilliant” idea of using Zyklon B, and first tested it on 600 Soviet prisoners, in Auschwitz, I believe? Industrial mass murder. A rupture of civilisation.

They were sick, crammed-together, poor people in a basement, and he simply threw in a little Zyklon B first, to test what would happen, and lo and behold, these people died a wretched death, but it took quite a long time. And then they refined it, this whole system, used more Zyklon B, gassed the Jews and were thus able to increase “production”. This precision – so far only the Germans have managed that. No other nation in a genocide installed this precision machine, out of engineering skill and genius, to annihilate people at an industrial pace. And I shudder when I think that this wasn’t all that long ago, that there are still people alive who can bear witness to it.

That was the propaganda

Then, in another documentary, I also watched the beginning of the Wehrmacht’s invasion of the Soviet Union again. And although of course I know all of this and have often read and heard about it, I’m still amazed once again at the unbelievable propaganda the Wehrmacht, or rather the Nazis, built up among the population back then with regard to racial ideology. In Munich and at other universities there were institutes for so-called racial hygiene. And there it was scientifically fixed that there were inferior races, inferior life, which had to be annihilated and eradicated. And this inferior life included all the so-called Slavic races – they were Untermenschen, subhumans. That was the propaganda. That means the Nazis didn’t only want to annihilate the Jews, but all the so-called inferior races unworthy of life. And that led to the Wehrmacht committing atrocities, above all in Ukraine too, that were unparalleled until then.

Hide from the men in the black coats

Today I talked for a long time with a Ukrainian woman, born in 1995, who told me that her grandparents had told her that they were more or less protected from the SS by the German soldiers, and that they were told: “Hide from the men in the black coats.” The SS officers mostly wore black coats. But that was perhaps the exception. I believe that for the most part the Wehrmacht took no prisoners, as had actually been customary in war for centuries; instead, above all, it shot the so-called commissars immediately, on the spot, in Ukraine, and also carried out crimes, cruel crimes against the civilian population.

So who were actually the subhumans?

And then, when the Wehrmacht was pushed back by the Red Army, around three million members of the Wehrmacht became prisoners of war, mostly in Russia. How did the Soviet Union deal with the members of the Wehrmacht who had committed terrible atrocities in Poland too and then above all in Ukraine? Did they repay like with like, even though they were supposedly the subhumans? No, by the standards of the time they treated the Germans in a very civilised way. In part they even nursed them. In the camps, in the prisoner-of-war camps, there were sick bays. And I believe the majority of prisoners in Soviet captivity survived and came back. They were allowed to come back. That means they weren’t convicted either; they were allowed back to their homeland, back into their lives, after they had committed these atrocities. And if perhaps they hadn’t committed them personally, they also didn’t prevent their comrades from committing these atrocities.

And that’s why the question arises: so who were actually the subhumans? Were they the Germans, or were they the Slavic people? I believe that we still don’t really own up to how our recent history unfolded.

Handing personal responsibility upwards

And of course there are scientists who study this, but the population – we have to engage with it, not a handful of selected scientists. Because that was exactly the problem with the Wehrmacht, too: the members of the Wehrmacht, the soldiers, shifted the responsibility and personally no longer had to face the atrocities they themselves had also committed. They simply said: it wasn’t us, Hitler gave the order, it was our Führer. That means handing personal responsibility upwards. And the terrible thing is that the Wehrmacht belt buckle said “Gott mit uns” – God with us. There too: of course Christianity, with the knights, with the crusaders, was also very violent at times, but at its core Christianity, the religion, is also very humane and built on peace and humanity and love, love of one’s neighbour. So much went wrong there that it simply must not be that we have already forgotten it again, quite obviously.

What does big politics have to do with me?

Because we experience exactly this shifting of responsibility every day now, too. We say it now as well: well, okay, Gaza and Ukraine and so on, yes, yes, that may well be, it’s not good. Could be that something is going wrong there, but what can I do? I’m a small person, I can’t do anything at all. I don’t have enough money, I have completely different worries, everyday worries. The petrol for my nice car is too expensive, and the mulled wine now costs, no idea, 7 euros. Well, what does big politics have to do with me? I have no influence on that anyway.

We have also failed completely in education there. What other nations do is another question, but we as a nation that started a world war twice, that is responsible for the Holocaust, and that would not have been stopped if the Allies – who finally landed in the end, after so many years – and the Soviet Army had not stopped the Wehrmacht and the Nazis by force: then it would have ended far worse. Would the Nazis and the Germans perhaps have annihilated half of the world’s population? We don’t know where they would have stopped, how far the Holocaust would then have gone.

That is far worse than corruption

And we also like to point the finger at others and say: they are all corrupt. Ukraine is highly corrupt, only we aren’t. I just looked at the pictures again. In Auschwitz, then, the gas chambers were built. That was the final stage in the evolution of the concentration camps and the extermination camps. They were extermination camps, not concentration camps. Nothing was concentrated there. And the Nazis wrote “Zum Baden” – “to the baths” – on them.

So, when we talk about corruption: what actually is corruption? In my view – the simple definition for me is – corruption means not keeping to rules that were agreed transparently. Transparent rules were adopted in a community, in a society, and they were communicated transparently, and people consciously don’t keep to these rules. And it is far more perfidious when a public authority – because the SS was a public authority, after all, it was legitimised; in the sense of the time they weren’t criminals but officials – when officials then write “to the baths” on it, then it is an even more perfidious, more perverse form of corruption. That is far worse than corruption.

That is megalomania

And we still have traces of this ideology. We still babble on about economic growth. For 80 years now we have had peace and huge economic growth every year, and we are still shouting: from right to left the consensus is that we in Germany need even more economic growth. We need even more steel, we need even more plastic, we need even more chemicals, we need even more of everything. We need even more cars, even more motorways. That is all madness, that is megalomania, and it began with Hitler. He too was already completely megalomaniac. We wanted to conquer the whole world, we were on the Western Front in France, we attacked the whole world because we wanted to build the German Reich, the Third Reich. And we haven’t really closed that chapter completely. That just isn’t true; there is still a lot of it in our daily routines, in our daily thinking, in our patterns of behaviour – a lot of it is still in there.

And where are we now, at the end of 2026?

We dehumanise other population groups, we still classify people, and we call the whole thing democracy. What bothers me about it is that for a long time we let ourselves be celebrated for supposedly upholding democracy. But if we are honest with ourselves, we don’t.

These many soldiers’ graves that are still cared for

„Gib unserem kleinen putzigen Herzele viele süße Kusseln von mir.“ (“Give our cute little Herzele lots of sweet kisses from me.”)

I found this phrase with “Herzele” in a ZDF documentary about a Wehrmacht soldier who was then killed on the Eastern Front, and his daughter was interviewed. She also said that she travelled to Russia, visited a grave of German soldiers there and held a memorial devotion there with three Russians.

So this, too, shows what humanity the Russians showed back then – that they acknowledged the suffering that the German soldiers themselves also went through on Russian soil. These many soldiers’ graves that are still cared for, in Russia too and in other countries as well, in the Netherlands for example, probably in France too – that bears witness to the fact that the other nations, nationalities and ethnic groups were not “Untermenschen” (“subhumans”) at all.

Show fact-check & sources
Something to think about

Who would you like to talk to about this thought?

Three ways from here